Skip to main content
All guides

Guide

How to compare supplier quotations line by line

Three quotations for the same request rarely quote the same thing. Before the lowest total means anything, each offer has to be brought to the same basis, and then compared line by line, on more than price.

Bring every offer to the same basis

  • The same unit and quantity on every line.
  • The same currency, with prices either all including or all excluding VAT.
  • Delivery to the same place: add transport where a supplier quoted from its own premises.
  • The same scope: note what each offer leaves out — testing, installation, certificates.

Compare line by line, not only the total

The lowest total can hide a line priced far above the others. Comparing each line shows where the savings really are, and lets you award different lines to different suppliers when that costs less overall.

Look beyond price

  • Delivery time, against the date you need.
  • Payment terms: an advance has a cost, and a longer credit period is worth money.
  • Deviations from the specification, and whether a technical reviewer accepts them.
  • The supplier’s record: completed orders, on-time delivery, disputes.

Weigh what matters, and write it down

If price is not the only criterion, set the weights before you open the offers — for example, price 60, delivery 20 and payment terms 20 out of 100 — and score every supplier the same way. Weights written down first are what make the choice defensible to your approver and fair to the suppliers.

Record the decision

Keep the comparison, the scores and the reason for the award with the purchase. Above your approval threshold, send it to the approver before you commit.

The comparison sheet

The sheet takes up to five suppliers. Enter each line’s quantity and every supplier’s unit price: it computes the line totals, the lowest price on each line and each supplier’s total, with rows for delivery time, payment terms and deviations.

General practice, not legal or tax advice: each buyer’s own rules and the law in force come first.

Do it on Fox Forces

Post the lines as an RFQ: they reach only the verified suppliers in each category who serve your governorate, and the offers come back side by side.